Historic Charm, Modern Luxury!

The Red Pepperoni

Hours: M-Sa 10 a.m. - 8 p.m.          Open: Daily          Cost: $$          Group Size: 2 to 6

pasta with red sauce and slice of bread

About the Restaurant

The Red Pepperoni was opened in 2012 and has been voted the best pizza in Madison. Their motto is "Fresh Food Fast," and they fulfill it by making their own pizza dough and using the freshest ingredients for toppings. Locals say they are always given just the right amount of food and toppings while dining here. They also talk about the large portion sizes.

The Menu

You can pick your own toppings or choose from one of the restaurant's specialty creations. Some of the toppings you can choose from are:
  • Pepperoni
  • Sausage
  • Bacon
  • Onions
  • Mushrooms
  • Pineapple
  • Banana Peppers
  • Feta Cheese
  • And more!

They also serve entrees like: 
  • Meatball Subs,
  • Chicken Parmesan,
  • Stromboli,
  • Baked Lasagna,
  • and Baked Ziti. 

Some of the best craft beer selections are also at The Red Pepperoni, with options from over 50 beer selections. 
close up of spaghetti and meatballs

Guest Reviews

Exceptional food and fine service to match

The Mac Daddy is a favorite of mine and my friend that frequent The Red Pepperoni as often as we can! We were discussing the fact we've never had one of their pizzas. I said, if they're as good as the calzones, they'd be awesome. Exceptional food and fine service to match, always....

Mikal Moore, Google

Such a fun and delicious place to eat

Such a fun and delicious place to eat. We were visiting from out of town with kids. This local restaurant comes up in all the searches so we thought we better give it a try. It's small and quaint. Makes you feel a flash back in time a bit. Great service. If you are used to a fast cheap carry out pizza, this may seem a little pricey. Their daily specials are affordable. 5 people, 2 pizzas and bread sticks. We were quite full when done.

- Barb, Google

One of the best I have had

A tiny pizza shop, yet one of the best I have had. Service was fast and friendly even during the busy evening hours. My wife had a personal pizza and I a calzone. Both were excellent and well made. Highly recommend!

- Kyle Winters, Google

Ready to Visit? Book your Stay with us Today!